The cheapest way for a small business to take card payments is the option with the lowest total cost for its own mix of takings, once the per-payment rate, any fixed or monthly fees, the card types customers use and the cost of getting money into the bank are all added together. A headline rate on its own rarely tells the whole story.
Understand what you are paying for
When a customer pays by card, the merchant's bank (the acquirer) pays an interchange fee to the customer's bank (the issuer). Interchange fees usually form part of the merchant service charge (MSC) that the business pays its bank. The Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) explains that the Interchange Fee Regulation caps certain interchange fees, limiting them to 0.2% of the value of a transaction for consumer debit cards and 0.3% for consumer credit cards where the caps apply. The IFR caps interchange fees but does not cap the merchant service charge, so the total a business pays depends on its provider's pricing as well.
Since 13 January 2018, shops are not allowed to charge customers extra for paying with certain payment methods, including a card capped by the Interchange Fee Regulation, with limited exceptions.
Compare the main cost lines
Before comparing providers, list the costs that apply to your business:
- Per-payment rate: the percentage charged on each in-person card payment.
- Online or invoice rate: often higher than the in-person rate.
- Monthly or plan fees: some providers charge a monthly fee for a lower rate.
- Payout costs: whether standard transfers are free and how quickly money reaches your account.
- Hardware: the price of a card reader or terminal, and whether it needs a phone.
SumUp's comparison pages list a standard in-person fee of 1.69%, with eligible fees reduced to 0.99% under its £19 a month Payments Plus plan. Square's comparison page lists an in-person fee of 1.75%, and Zettle's lists the same 1.75% standard in-person fee, with custom pricing for businesses processing £10,000 or more per month.
Those published rates are useful only once they are applied to your own takings.
Work out your own cheapest option
Use this checklist with your last three months of card statements:
- Total your card takings for a typical month.
- Split them into in-person and online or invoice payments.
- Note the card types you take, such as debit, credit and commercial cards.
- Add up every fee on your current statement, including the MSC and any monthly charges.
- Note how often you need money moved to your bank and what that costs.
- Apply each provider's published rates to the same monthly figures.
Two worked examples
The figures below are examples only, not your takings. They use the in-person rates quoted above and ignore hardware and online fees to keep the comparison simple.
Example one: a café taking £4,000 a month in person. The gap of £2.40 a month is small, so the decision might rest on payout speed or hardware rather than the rate alone.
Example two: a shop taking £15,000 a month in person. Whether that plan pays off depends on which of your payments count as eligible, so check the plan terms and your own statement before deciding.
In both examples, the cheapest option is the one that gives the lowest total after every fee is included. The IFR caps also apply to certain fees relating to some American Express card transactions, so check how a provider treats them.




